With the world’s attention
focused on the War Against Terrorism, scant attention is being given to
a potential breakthrough in the longstanding conflict between Muslims
and non-Muslims on Cyprus. The Cyprus problem is a microcosm of the larger
ethnic conflict that extends across much of Europe and Asia.
Since early this year the Turkish Cypriot leader, Rauf Denktash, and his
Greek counterpart, Cypriot President Glafcos Clerides, have been quietly
meeting face-to-face three mornings a week negotiating the details of
an agreement to end the ethnic conflict that broke out after a shrinking
British Empire pulled out of Cyprus in 1960. The breakthrough occurred
after Denktash agreed late last year that he was willing to meet with
Clerides to try to end the impasse.
A year before, Denktash had scuttled UN-led "proximity talks,"
insisting on international recognition of the Turkish Republic of North
Cyprus before face-to-face negotiations could begin. This was not the
first time Denktash (with Turkey’s support) had pulled the rug out
from under UN efforts to solve the Cyprus problem. Denktash, the leader
of the Turkish Cypriots for more than 40 years, enjoys hero status in
Turkey, where he is seen as the savior of the Turkish Cypriots on an island
where Greeks outnumber Turks by more than four to one. When Denktash pulled
out of the UN-led proximity talks in November 2000, he was supported by
Turkey’s Prime Minister Bulent Ecevit and its influential military.
This might have been business as usual in the long-playing Cyprus saga,
but for the fact that Turkey is now a candidate for European Union membership.
When Denktash said "no" this last time, voices in Turkey proclaimed
"enough." Media, business leaders and, for the first time, responsible
politicians realized that an unresolved Cyprus stood in the way of Turkey’s
larger strategic interests in moving toward the West. As they saw it,
the Cyprus tail was wagging the Turkish dog. They realized that, for Turkey,
the road to the EU runs through Nicosia, Cyprus’ capital.
With Cyprus’ own accession into the EU expected in December, Denktash
and his supporters in Turkey were faced with a hard choice. Either they
abandon hope for a political solution allowing Cyprus to enter the EU,
with the Turkish northern third of the island left behind. Or they come
to an agreement with the Greek Cypriots before Cyprus slipped away. With
few cards left to play, Denktash reversed course, leading to the negotiations
now underway.
Major hurdles remain. Territory in the north will have to go back to the
Greek side. Property claims on both sides need to be settled. Security
arrangements must be put in place and a new government for a unified Cyprus
agreed to.
Security issues may be the easiest to solve. As President Clinton told
Ecevit in their Oval Office meeting in 1999, there is no going back to
the Cyprus that existed before 1974, when Turkish troops occupied the
northern third of the island after the Turkish minority had been increasingly
marginalizes and physically attacked by the Greek majority. Issues of
governance are difficult for both sides, but not intractable. The Turkish
side is rightly insisting on safeguards to protect its minority interests
while the Greek side prefers a majoritarian democracy.
Turkish Cypriots fear domination by the Greek majority whom they view
as essentially hostile and aggressive. Greek Cypriots see Turkish troops
occupying one-third of the island, and 60,000 mainland settlers, as an
invasion of their island. Children of a lesser god is the way many Greek
Cypriots view their Turkish neighbors to the north.
That said, there is a genuine basis for optimism. Both Denktash and Clerides
realize this is their last hurrah. These venerable leaders, one 78, the
other 83, have been at it for more than four decades. Neither can see
anyone on the horizon to take their place. The next generation will not
have known a time when Greeks and Turks lived peacefully together as neighbors.
Moreover, if agreement is not reached this year, Cyprus will slip away
and the division on Cyprus is likely to become permanent. If that happens,
the northern third of the island, which is not self sustainable, will
look to join Turkey, making Ecevit’s threat to annex real, scuttling
Turkey’s EU ambitions.
If Denktash and Clerides are serous about a united Cyprus that protects
the fundamental interests of the two sides, it can happen now; and if
Muslims and non-Muslims can live together on Cyprus, it could turn out
to be the harbinger of peace in the larger conflict that affects the world.
Having set the stage for the present talks, the United States and others
should stand back and quietly encourage both sides to reach agreement.